I am challenged when I read my friend’s message that one of the readers’ of my posts was confused reading my writing about polygamy. Here I try to clarify my previous writing. In that writing, I expressed my opinion that I am not against polygamy (how can I oppose something that God allows it?) But again, God allows it with some conditions. The man must be fair, and he won’t be able-this is stated in Qur’an. I am not against polygamy when it is done in proper such as the first wife agrees to it. The first wife, must be sincere when she says it is OK. And the husband should not in any way force or even threaten his wife. When there is a good intention from all the parties: the husband, the wife and the new wife, polygamy may create happiness too. The wives can be good friends, even stronger than just friends. In my opinion, polygamy is fine when it meets the following criteria.
First, the polygamy has got a reasonable reason ( is there a reason for polygamy except to satisfy male sexual desire? I think there is, and it varies). Yet, I am strongly against when its reason is ridiculous, such as men have greater libido so it’s natural for him to have more than wife or using sunnah Rosul for his justification while his reason is merely for having a new woman to taste.
Second, the husband must have both responsibility and ability to provide a good living for his families. (So, do not marry a jerk who just wanna make use of women for sex and money only).
Third, he must try to be fair. (Why I use the word ‘try”? Coz, can he be fair? In material may be, but surely not in feeling, love or care. Even a mother or father has an unconscious tendency to love one of his/her children more than the other ones right? Though of course, they try to show it in order not to hurt the other children.
Fourth, the first wife must agree it sincerely. (My feminist friend says that there are only 2 or 3 of 100 women will let her husband marry again). For this case, I am proud of women who can be sincere to share the happiness that she has got from her husband with other women. It is a very hard thing to do, right? And I am also proud of men who keep monogamy though his wife allows him to do polygamy.
Fifth, the parents must also ask the children’s opinion. If they do not agree, it is better to cancel the plan as it may be destructive to the children’s future.
Well, I found an interesting case related to a recent incident that happened to Mayang sari ( She is a well-known singer in Indonesia who recently shocked the public by being pregnant and giving a birth without telling public who her baby’s father was. But, soon it is known that she is Bambang triatmojo’s mistress). Bambang’s first wife named Halimah and his children came to Mayang’s house and apparently violence occurred. This incident got much attention from public as the people involved are public figures. Bambang himself is one of the sons of Soeharto-the former president of Indonesia.
When I heard this incident, the first and sudden thing came to my mind was how a wrong polygamy has destroyed a family. In my perspective, some of the points I mentioned above aren’t fulfilled in the marriage of Bambang and Mayang.
First,
what reason that made Bambang marry Mayang? He’s got a beautiful wife and nice children (I see this as an outsider of course. I do not know exactly whether their marriage is actually fragile or have already been bad before he marries his mistress).Is it due to love? May be (for this reason, I can’t give any comment. Love can falls to anyone and anytime. But I have a strong doubt that he does it to protect or lead his second wife to be a Moslem just like what the prophet Muhammad did. Mayang is already Moslem. Does he intend to create a strong, harmonious and big family by marrying his mistress? I don’t think so. That’s because he seemingly already had the affair long ago. His second controversial marriage (I really do not think it is a legal one) is the ultimate sign that he chooses to ruin his family rather than maintain it.
What about Mayang herself? I feel a pity on her. She knows that Halimah does not approve her affair. Why does she go on? Doesn’t she think of Halimah’s children? I was not impressed with her appearance in public some days after her secret was disclosed. She acted as if nothing went wrong to her She said that it was her life. She had chosen it and would take its consequences. (But, it ‘s not only her that got the pain. Her choice had ruined a family). Yet, I am glad that she said to public later on that she learned a lot from the incident.
Second, is Bambang able to provide a good living for his both family? Of course, he is. His father’s wealth is so abundant that he can inherit it till the seventh generation . For this reason, he is oke.
Third, can he be fair? The fact that he makes Mayang as his mistress and the incident happened in Mayang’s dwelling shows that he insisted on his own sake regardless the feeling of Halimah, Gendis and Panji (his children). Is he fair, having fun with his mistress while his wife and children get hurt? Absolutely not. Being fair means trying to make none hurt.
Fourth and fifth, it is clearly seen that Bambang neither gets his first wife’s approval nor his children’s. When two parties are against, will there be a happy life?
Anyway, I also regret Halimah’s deed though she might do it to maintain her marriage or coz of love. I can’t also just suggest “ leave and forget him!”. They have got married for ages, it may not be easy for Halimah to forget the old good days. If she still wants to keep her marriage, she’d better turn her anger of being betrayed to positive things. She’s got a handsome and rich husband, and nice kids. Though now her husband chooses to be with another woman, she’d better let him go. He’ll be back if he is her real soul mate. When he kneels begging to be back, that’s your victory!). So, what should she do now? She’d better try to enjoy what God has bestowed to. Getting closer to her children will give her strength. Dedicating more time to help the needy will give a peace to her heart. When there is another man who really loves her and she feels happy and secure with him. Why not marrying him, who knows he is her postponed soul mate .
Well, that is an example of the impact of false polygamy.